Nolan Cicero is a 6'4", 304-pound offensive lineman from Crown Point, Indiana, where he attended Crown Point High School. A three-year varsity starter on the offensive line, Cicero helped the Bulldogs compile a 35-3 record and reached the IHSAA 6A state championship finals as a sophomore and a semi-state championship in his junior year. He earned all-conference honors his senior season and also competed in wrestling. Cicero signed with Ball State in December 2025 after receiving offers from Miami, Toledo, and Bowling Green. The true freshman may see offensive line opportunities during the 2026 season.

Ball State2026 — present